Open vs. Closed Office Space?

One of the unique opportunities – and challenges – when moving your office location is the chance to redesign the layout.  Where does everybody sit?  Who is near the windows?  Are there private offices or not?  Our senior management has recently begun wrestling with this question while we narrow down our list of potential new homes.  Paul, our space planner, recently gave a presentation and discussed the pros and cons of different design strategies to the senior management team.  The discussion ranged from noise levels, privacy, cross-functional productivity, and how teams can collaborate together more effectively.  A big issue that also emerged was that of corporate culture, and our staff’s capacity for change.  Moving too far to the extremes of either option could simply be counterproductive.

From an energy efficiency perspective – the question has some interesting ramifications.  If closed offices are on the perimeter, will daylighting be diminished?  Access to daylight is a big issue for our staff. Can that be moderated by glass versus solid wall construction?  Is there an energy penalty due to closed offices?  What lighting strategies are deployed – task lights at each desk or standard ceiling illumination – or both?  The choice between an open versus closed plan seems to be a major crossroads – once we choose a direction, some energy saving opportunities open up while others may close.  It will be fascinating to work with Paul and his team to understand the implications of this decision, and how we can still get energy efficient space that meets our work style.


One response to “Open vs. Closed Office Space?

  1. Interesting choice for office layout. Lets see,
    do you want a small privileged class out in the
    periphery with window views only they enjoy?,
    or a larger share of desirable /healthy space that
    less senior staff can also enjoy?

    The only way to increase “window seats” is with
    an indoor atrium. Also required is modular wall
    systems with hvac/electrical underneath false floors,
    (much like the computer rooms of the 60’s and 70’s)
    so you can change room configuration in a matter of
    hours, rather than weeks .

    With modular wall system,future renovation eliminates
    remodel waste such as drywall, electrical wire devices, etc.
    and not to mention the dust and labor involved.

    A good example of this open atrium is F.L. Wright’s commercial
    building out east somewhere. Also you can incorporate innovative
    daylight with the use of heliostats, prisim,light shelves etc.
    for the artistic bent among us. Much like BOMAN SOLAR’S installation
    out east for a pharmaceutical companywhich “throws” sunlight into
    the interior with the use of mirrors.

    Remember people operate at their best in a natural light type environment
    because they are more healthy and vibrant.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s